LOST IN OVERTIME
Second Chance, Hockey MMF
Why Choose Romance
by Claudia Burgoa
April 15th 2026
BLURB
Two Rivals. One Woman. No Choosing.
Alberto Wade and Callaway Winthrop were my best friends first—until one night broke us, and the three of us stopped being an us.
Now they’re enemies in the league, an “infamous rivalry” splashed across headlines like it’s just hockey.
It isn’t.
It’s me.
It’s what they’ve always wanted and have never been able to agree on.
It’s the way their hate on the ice has always sounded too much like longing off it.
Now, a shocking trade and an emergency back home drag us back into the same orbit. Older. harder. Still dangerous. Still looking at me like I’m the only thing they’ve ever wanted.
They still want to win.
They still want me.
I still refuse to choose.
But second chances come with scars, secrets, and promises we never got to finish—until a single mistake turns into two pink lines . . .
I’m pregnant—with a baby that isn’t theirs.
The timing is brutal. The fallout is inevitable. And the only way we survive what comes next is if they stop making me choose—stop pretending their rivalry is the only fire between them—and finally admit what’s been burning between all three of us all along.
Because this time . . .
They’re not just fighting for a season.
They’re fighting for us.
USA Today Bestselling Author Claudia Burgoa delivers a deeply angsty MMF why-choose hockey romance featuring two pro-hockey rivals, the woman they can’t stop loving, hurt/comfort, found family, and a love that risks careers, reputations, and the one thing they never meant to want—each other.
The Book Junkie Reads . . . Review of . . . LOST IN OVERTIME . . . Lost in Overtime: A 5-Star Why-Choose Masterpiece!
Claudia Burgoa has delivered an MMF romance that doesn't just push boundaries—it shatters them. This second-chance hockey romance between Vesper, Monty, and Callaway is the definition of "intense." While the ebook was a solid, gripping experience, the audio took it to a whole new level.
The Trio: Rivals, Friends, and the "Why Choose" Dream
The "Why Choose" trope is your personal brand of "fairytale in real life," and this book executes it to perfection. Vesper is a heroine after my own heart—fiercely independent, sharp-tongued, and wielding sarcasm like a shield. She’s the anchor for two men who have been at each other’s throats in the league for years.
Monty (The Stoic Goalie): The strong, protective hero with a "tender underbelly" that only Vesper truly sees.
Callaway (The Golden Boy): The man who just wants the people he loves to love him back with "no reservations."
The added stakes of the "two pink lines"—a pregnancy that complicates an already messy, yearning-filled past—raised the angst to a fever pitch. It forced them to stop playing the "rivalry" game and finally address the fire burning between all three of them.
The Narration: Erin Mallon, Robert Hatchet, & Gomez Pugh
The audio was "amazing," and that’s down to this trio of narrators who really understood the assignment:
Erin Mallon: You already know she’s a favorite of mine, and she nails Vesper’s sharp, sarcastic edge while making her vulnerability feel earned.
Robert Hatchet & Gomez Pugh: These two were new to me, but they brought incredible "sauce" to the roles of Monty and Callaway. They captured the raw yearning, the stubbornness, and the deep-seated history between the two hockey rivals perfectly.
Why This Hockey MMF Wins:
The "Real Life" Fantasy: Burgoa handles the MMF dynamic with such care, showing that "Why Choose" isn't just about the heat—it’s about the emotional connection that creates a true "us."
Heart-Wrenching Angst: The friends-to-lovers-to-enemies-to-lovers arc is a rollercoaster, but the "heartfelt" resolution makes the pain worth it.
The "Added Factor": Pregnancy tropes in a Why Choose romance are risky, but here it acted as the ultimate catalyst for them to finally drop the act and fight for the family they could be.
My Final Verdict
Lost in Overtime is a triumph of the Why Choose genre. It’s a "passion-filled" dive into a second-chance romance that proves when you find the people who fit your soul, you never have to choose—you just have to grow together. A 5-star standout that confirms Burgoa’s status as a master of the hockey romance!
Tropes:
🏒MMF
💜Second Chance Romance
🏒Hockey Romance
💜Forced Proximity
🏒Rivals-To-Lovers
💜Bi- Awakening
🏒Best Friends to Lovers
💜Possessive/Protective Heroes
🏒Surprise Pregnancy (Not Theirs)









